The bright band is gas moving around the black hole. Matter collects in a thin disk and gradually travels inward. This inward movement is accretion. The hot gas emits the light that makes the surroundings visible.
Gas like this gave away the first system that astronomers widely believed to hold a black hole. Cygnus X-1 was found as a source of X-rays in 1964. In 1972, two separate studies showed that its bright star circles an unseen, massive companion. Its mass is now put at about 20 times the Sun’s.
A black hole can also be alone, with little material nearby to feed such a disk. This picture shows one with gas around it, giving us a view we would lose if the gas were gone.
The gas belongs to a flat disk. Light from its far side follows the curved paths of space-time near the black hole and reaches us above the dark center. The disk appears to rise into an arch.
Gravity’s bending of light was first measured during the total solar eclipse of 29 May 1919. Two British expeditions, one led by Arthur Eddington, photographed stars near the darkened Sun and found them shifted by a little under two arcseconds, in line with Einstein’s prediction. Near a black hole the same bending is strong enough to lift the far side of the disk into view.
Look below the foreground band too. Another path brings light from the underside of the far side into view there. Our viewing angle changes these shapes. Looking straight down on the disk would give a very different picture.
Light that passes through the event horizon cannot reach us again. Gravity also bends nearby paths of light. Together, these effects create the dark region called the black hole’s shadow.
The horizon first appeared on paper. Within two months of Einstein publishing his field equations in 1915, Karl Schwarzschild, an artillery lieutenant on the Russian front, found an exact solution for the space around a single mass. It contains a radius, now named after him, from inside which nothing can escape. He died soon afterward, still in military service.
The shadow looks larger than the event horizon within it. The dark shape in this painting marks the shadow; its edge does not give us a view of the horizon itself.
The fine rim around the shadow represents a photon ring. It contains highly distorted images of the disk, made by light that traveled around the black hole more than once before escaping toward us.
In the model there are multiple rings, becoming thinner and fainter closer to the shadow. The painting simplifies them into a narrow line. The broad arch farther out is another image of the disk, with a different path to our eyes.
The left side is brighter in this view because the gas there is moving toward us. Close to the black hole, its orbital speed is high enough for relativity to change the brightness of the light we receive. The receding side appears dimmer.
This effect is called Doppler beaming. The contrast depends on our angle to the moving gas. Viewed from directly above the disk, that difference between approaching and receding sides would disappear.
The 2019 image of the black hole in the galaxy M87 shows the same effect. Its ring is brighter on one side, and the Event Horizon Telescope team traced the difference to gas on that side moving toward us.
In 1978, Jean-Pierre Luminet calculated how a black hole surrounded by a thin gas disk would look. He used an IBM 7040 computer at the Paris-Meudon Observatory, feeding it punched cards. To turn the numbers into an image, he placed ink dots on negative image paper, more densely where his calculation predicted more light, then reversed the image. The image first appeared in November 1978 in La Recherche, a French popular science magazine, and then in a technical journal in 1979. It already showed the distorted disk and unequal brightness that make this shape recognizable. The watercolor above is a new interpretation, not a copy of Luminet’s image.
On 10 April 2019, the Event Horizon Telescope collaboration released the first image of a black hole’s shadow, at the center of the galaxy M87. Eight radio telescopes had collected the measurements in 2017; their combined data were used to reconstruct the image. A bright, uneven ring surrounded a dark center, broadly agreeing with the features predicted by earlier models. It was an observed image made from radio light. The painted disk above shows a different viewing angle, using an illustration to make individual paths of light easier to explore.
The interior raises a question of its own. In the simple, non-rotating model pictured here, general relativity predicts a central singularity, where matter reaches infinite density. Astronomers do not know whether this describes something physical or marks a limit of the mathematics. Quantum effects may become essential there. The dark center in the painting represents the shadow seen from outside; it does not show the singularity.
A white hole reverses the classical black-hole idea: matter and light can leave it, while nothing can enter. Stephen Hawking discussed white holes in his 1976 paper on black-hole thermodynamics, examining their relationship to black holes through time reversal. This was a theoretical argument. No white hole has been confirmed by observation, and a possible connection to a black hole remains speculative.
Quasars once entered this speculation too. Some scientists considered whether their extraordinary brightness might come from white holes. Observations instead support a different explanation. A quasar is the intensely luminous active center of a galaxy, powered by gas falling toward a supermassive black hole. The light comes from material around the hole, before it crosses the event horizon. The black hole and the quasar name different parts of that system.
A watercolor interpretation of a non-rotating black hole, based on NASA visualizations by Jeremy Schnittman and Robert Hurt. The colors and brushwork are artistic choices; the picture represents the arrangement of the light qualitatively. The story above includes the Event Horizon Telescope’s 2019 radio image of M87*.